"I Feel Like You're Against Me"
- adam mccutchen
- May 4
- 7 min read
Rick thought the meeting had gone well.
He had laid out the new performance expectations clearly, walked the team through the updated workflow, and even stayed late to answer questions. He drove home that night feeling like he had handled it professionally. Then, the next morning, his direct report Janelle stopped him in the hallway before he could even grab his coffee.
"Rick, I need to be honest with you. It feels like you're against me."
He smiled, said "of course I'm not," and told her they should schedule some time to talk. Then he walked to his office, closed the door, and stared at his computer screen for twenty minutes without reading a single word.
The Moment Most Leaders Fail Before They Even Speak
Here is the hard truth: most leaders respond to that kind of feedback by defending themselves. They replay the meeting in their head. They catalog all the fair, reasonable things they have done. They build a case, and then they deliver it, politely but firmly, to the person who just made themselves vulnerable enough to say something out loud.
That response feels justified. It also completely misses the point.
When an employee tells you they feel like you are against them, they are not filing a formal complaint. They are handing you something fragile, something they have probably been carrying for weeks. What you do in that moment, not in the scheduled follow-up meeting, not in the email you craft carefully afterward, but in that exact moment, will define the kind of leader you actually are.
Rick got his second chance when Janelle came to his office that afternoon. This time, he did not defend himself. He did not explain. He pulled up a chair, sat down across from her, and said, "Tell me more. I want to understand."
N: Navigate the Messy Middle
This is the part no leadership book prepares you for. Not the conflict itself, but the silence after you ask the hard question. The discomfort of sitting with someone's perception of you when every instinct in your body is screaming to correct the record.
Navigating the messy middle means you stay in the room, emotionally and physically, when everything in you wants to leave. It means you do not rush to resolution. You do not minimize what someone is feeling because their feelings do not match your intentions. And you do not trade their honesty for your comfort.
Janelle told Rick that every time she offered an idea in team meetings, he moved on quickly, without acknowledgment. She said the new workflow changes had come down without any input from her, even though she was the one closest to the process. She was not accusing him of being a bad person. She was telling him that the gap between his intentions and his impact had quietly grown into something that felt like exclusion.
That is what navigating looks like. You listen until you understand something you did not know before you walked into the room.
What the Gap Between Intent and Impact Actually Costs You
Leaders who skip the navigation step do not usually lose their employees in a dramatic moment. They lose them in a hundred small ones, the unacknowledged idea, the change that came without context, the meeting that ended before the quietest person in the room ever spoke. Retention is not just about salary or benefits. It is about whether people feel seen by the person who is supposed to be leading them.
When Janelle said "I feel like you're against me," she was not being dramatic. She was describing the slow, quiet erosion of trust that happens when a leader operates on autopilot. Rick was not trying to exclude her. But good intentions that go unexamined do not protect you from the damage they cause.
The leaders who build real loyalty are not the ones who never mess up. They are the ones who take it seriously when someone tells them the impact does not match the intent, and then they actually do something about it.
I: Identify the Leadership Moment Hidden Inside the Hard Conversation
Here is what Rick almost missed: Janelle coming to him was a gift. Most employees do not say anything. They withdraw. They go quiet in meetings. They start updating their resumes. The fact that she walked up to him in that hallway meant she had not given up. She still believed, even if barely, that he was worth talking to.
That is a leadership moment, and it was already happening before Rick even recognized it.
Your leadership moments are rarely the ones that feel important. They are not always the big presentations or the strategic planning sessions. Sometimes they are the person who catches you before your first cup of coffee and says something that makes your stomach drop. The question is whether you slow down long enough to see it.
Rick did not fix everything in one conversation. But he did something that mattered more, he made Janelle feel heard. And that changed the trajectory of their entire working relationship.
G: Grow the One Skill That Changes Everything Right Now
If this topic is hitting close to home, do not try to overhaul your entire leadership approach this week. That kind of pressure leads to paralysis, not progress. Instead, grow one skill: the ability to receive hard feedback without immediately defending yourself.
That skill has a name. It is called staying regulated under pressure. It means your nervous system does not hijack your better judgment the moment someone says something that feels like an attack on your character. It means you can hear "I feel like you're against me" and respond with curiosity instead of self-protection.
This is not a personality trait you either have or you do not. It is a practice. And like every practice, it starts awkwardly, gets uncomfortable, and eventually becomes the thing people describe when they talk about why they trust you.
Start small. The next time someone gives you feedback that stings, pause before you respond. Take one breath. Ask one follow-up question before you say a single word in your defense.
Im: Implement Today, Not After You Think About It
Here is your action step, and it is not optional.
Think of one person on your team who has gone quiet recently. Maybe they used to speak up in meetings and now they do not. Maybe their energy has shifted and you have been too busy to address it. Maybe there is a small, nagging sense that something is off and you have been filing it under "I'll get to that."
Get to it today.
You do not need a formal one-on-one scheduled two weeks out. You need to walk up to that person, or send a direct message, and say something simple: "Hey, I've noticed things feel a little different lately. I want to make sure I'm showing up well for you. Can we find ten minutes to connect?"
That is it. That is the whole action. It will feel awkward for about thirty seconds. What comes after that might be one of the most important leadership conversations you have all year.
T: Track the Small Moments That Build Big Trust
Trust is not built in grand gestures. It is built in the accumulation of small moments where you chose the harder, more honest path. Start paying attention to those moments this week.
Did you pause before defending yourself? Did you ask a follow-up question instead of explaining your intentions? Did you go back to someone after a difficult conversation and check in again? Those are wins. They may not feel like much, but they are the raw material of a culture where people feel safe enough to tell you the truth.
Keep a simple log if it helps. At the end of each week, write down one moment where you prioritized someone else's perspective over your own comfort. Over time, that log becomes evidence of the leader you are becoming, not the one you are performing.
E: Elevate Others by Making It Safe to Be Honest with You
The highest form of leadership is not the ability to inspire from a stage. It is the ability to create an environment where the quietest person in the room believes their voice matters. Where an employee can walk up to you in a hallway and say something hard, and trust that you will not make them regret it.
Janelle took a risk when she approached Rick. She did not know how he would respond. Every employee who gives honest feedback is taking that same risk. When you receive it well, you do not just help that one person. You send a message to every person watching that this team is a place where honesty is welcomed, not punished.
That is the work of elevating others. Not the recognition programs or the team lunches, although those matter too. The deepest form of elevation is making it safe for people to bring you their truth.
What You Take With You From Here
If someone on your team has ever felt like you were against them, you are not a bad leader. You are a human one. But the leaders who separate themselves are the ones who sit with that feedback instead of dismissing it, who navigate the discomfort instead of explaining it away, and who come out the other side more trustworthy than they were before.
The key takeaways from this week:
When an employee says they feel you are against them, your first job is to listen, not to correct. The gap between your intentions and your impact is real, even when your intentions are good.
Staying regulated under pressure is a learnable skill. Pause, breathe, and ask one follow-up question before defending yourself.
The employee who tells you the hard thing is giving you a gift. Most people go silent. The ones who speak up still believe in you.
Identify the leadership moments already happening around you. They rarely announce themselves. They show up in hallways, before coffee, in quiet shifts in body language.
Track the small wins. The pause. The follow-up question. The check-in you almost skipped. Those moments are building the leader you are becoming.
Elevating others starts with making it safe to be honest with you. That safety is not a policy. It is built one hard conversation at a time.
Rick did not have it all figured out after his conversation with Janelle. But something shifted. She stayed. She started speaking up in meetings again. And Rick learned something that no leadership training had ever taught him: the most powerful thing a leader can say is not "here is my plan." Sometimes, it is simply, "tell me more."
That is the kind of leadership that ignites potential and leads with purpose.


Comments